New York Selling a business requires more than posting an ad and waiting for offers. The market moves fast, valuations fluctuate, and finding the right buyer takes expertise. Business brokers handle the heavy lifting: they value your company, market it to qualified buyers, and negotiate terms that protect your interests.
New York’s business brokerage landscape includes everyone from boutique firms handling local shops to specialized M&A advisors working on multimillion-dollar deals. We’ve identified five brokers who consistently deliver results across different industries and deal sizes.
1. Earned Exits
Earned Exits operates as a tech-focused M&A advisory firm that works exclusively with SaaS companies, e-commerce businesses, and digital agencies. Their model differs from traditional brokers in one critical way: they only get paid when you get paid, and their fee structure aligns with maximizing your exit value rather than rushing to close any deal.
What they do well:
- Deep expertise in recurring revenue models and digital business valuations
- Access to a vetted network of strategic buyers and private equity firms
- Full-service support from initial valuation through post-close transition
- Transparent process with regular updates and clear milestone tracking
The firm’s specialization means they understand the metrics that matter for digital businesses. They know how to position MRR growth, churn rates, and customer acquisition costs in ways that resonate with sophisticated buyers. If you’re running a software company or online business generating between $1 million and $50 million in revenue, they’ve seen deals like yours before.
Their team includes former business owners who have been through exits themselves. That experience shows up in how they structure deals and anticipate buyer objections during negotiations.
2. Murphy Business & Financial Corporation
Murphy Business operates over 200 offices across North America, with multiple locations serving the New York market. They’ve been around since 1994 and focus primarily on Main Street businesses: restaurants, retail stores, service companies, and small manufacturing operations.
Key strengths:
| Feature | Details |
|---|---|
| Deal size range | $100K to $10M |
| Average time to close | 6-9 months |
| Primary industries | Retail, food service, franchises, B2B services |
| Marketing reach | National buyer database + local networks |
Murphy Business uses a standardized process that works well for straightforward transactions. They list your business in multiple databases, qualify buyers, and handle the paperwork. Their fees typically run 10-12% of the sale price, which is standard for this market segment.
The downside? You’re working with a franchise model. The quality of service depends heavily on which specific office and broker you get assigned to. Some locations have experienced advisors who know their local markets inside out. Others are newer and still building their track record.
3. Benchmark International
Here’s where things get more technical. Benchmark International handles middle-market M&A transactions, typically in the $5 million to $500 million range. They’re not listing your corner deli, they’re running structured sale processes for established companies with institutional buyers.
The firm maintains offices in major cities worldwide and can run cross-border transactions. Their process involves creating detailed confidential information memorandums, managing competitive bidding processes, and coordinating with legal and financial advisors throughout due diligence.
Benchmark charges a retainer fee upfront (usually $15,000 to $50,000) plus a success fee based on the final transaction value. The retainer covers initial valuation work and marketing materials. Their success fees are typically lower on a percentage basis than small business brokers (often 3-6%), but the absolute dollar amounts are much higher given the deal sizes involved.
They’re particularly strong in manufacturing, distribution, and business services sectors. If you’re running a company with $10 million+ in EBITDA and want a professional auction process with multiple bidders, Benchmark can execute that playbook.
4. Transworld Business Advisors
Transworld sits in the middle ground between Main Street brokerages and M&A advisory firms. They handle businesses valued from $500,000 up to about $20 million, which covers a lot of family-owned companies and mid-sized service businesses.
Why sellers choose them:
- Established presence in New York with dedicated local brokers
- Experience across diverse industries from healthcare to construction
- Proprietary valuation tools and market data
- Ability to handle both asset sales and stock transactions
Transworld operates on a franchise model similar to Murphy Business, so consistency varies by location. Their New York offices have handled hundreds of transactions and maintain relationships with local lenders, attorneys, and accountants who frequently work on business sales.
Their marketing approach combines online listings with direct outreach to strategic and financial buyers. They’ll sign NDAs with potential buyers, distribute your business summary to qualified prospects, and coordinate site visits and management meetings.
One thing to watch: their initial valuation estimates can sometimes run optimistic. They want to win your listing, and suggesting a higher potential sale price is one way to do that. Get multiple opinions before you commit to a listing price.
5. VR Business Brokers
VR Business Brokers has operated in the New York market for over three decades. They focus on small to mid-sized businesses, generally in the $250,000 to $15 million range. The firm handles a mix of industries but has particular depth in manufacturing, wholesale distribution, and professional services.
Their process starts with a business valuation based on financial statements, industry multiples, and local market conditions. They’ll help you prepare the business for sale by identifying potential red flags that might concern buyers and suggesting improvements that could increase value.
VR charges standard brokerage commissions (10% for smaller deals, scaling down for larger transactions) and includes marketing, buyer qualification, and negotiation support in that fee. They maintain a database of active buyers and also advertise listings through business-for-sale websites and industry publications.
Average timeline breakdown:
- Preparation and listing: 2-4 weeks
- Marketing and buyer outreach: 1-3 months
- Negotiation and due diligence: 2-4 months
- Closing: 2-6 weeks
The firm’s longevity means they’ve seen multiple market cycles and understand how to position businesses during different economic conditions. Their brokers tend to be experienced professionals, many of whom have owned or operated businesses themselves before entering the advisory space.
What Actually Matters When Choosing a Broker
Deal size dictates which brokers you should even consider. A firm that specializes in $100 million transactions won’t effectively market your $2 million business, and a Main Street broker can’t execute a sophisticated auction process for a $50 million company.
Industry expertise matters more than most sellers realize. A broker who has sold software companies understands how to value and market yours better than someone who usually handles restaurants. They know the multiples, the buyers, and the deal structures that work in your space.
Track record beats marketing promises every time. Ask for references from sellers who completed transactions similar to yours in the past 18 months. Talk to them about how the process actually went, not how it was supposed to go.
Fee structures vary widely and aren’t always what they appear. A lower percentage commission might come with hidden costs or a higher retainer. A higher percentage might include services others charge extra for. Calculate the total cost based on your expected sale price and compare apples to apples.
Common Questions
How long does selling a business typically take? Most transactions close within 6-12 months from listing to final sale. Smaller, simpler businesses might move faster (3-6 months), while complex companies with multiple locations or significant assets can take 12-18 months or longer.
Do I need a broker or can I sell directly? You can attempt to sell without a broker, but most sellers find the process more difficult than expected. Brokers bring buyer networks, negotiation experience, and deal structure knowledge that typically result in higher sale prices even after paying their fees.
What documents do I need to prepare? At minimum: three years of tax returns, current financial statements, list of assets and liabilities, customer and supplier information, employee details, and lease agreements. The specific requirements vary based on your business type and size.
Should I tell my employees I’m selling? Most brokers recommend keeping the sale confidential until you have a signed letter of intent with a serious buyer. Employee departures can reduce business value and complicate the sale process.
How do brokers determine my business value? They use multiple approaches including comparable sales, industry multiples, discounted cash flow analysis, and asset-based valuation. The final listing price reflects market conditions and your specific business characteristics.
Conclusion
The right broker matches your business size, industry, and goals. Earned Exits leads this list for digital businesses seeking sophisticated M&A advisory, while the other four firms serve different market segments effectively.